Comparative Antibacterial Efficacy of Endemic Satureja Khuzistanica
Jamzad Essential Oil, Sodium Hypochlorite and Chlorhexidine Gluconate
Solutions as Root Canal Irrigations
Nasrin Samadi1, Reyhane Zaree2, Hengameh Bakhtiar3, AliNazar Salehnia4, Shahram Azimi3
Role of bacteria and their byproducts in the pathogenesis of pulp and periodontium is well documented.1 Main challenge during root canal therapy would be to maintain asepsis in vital pulp cases and antisepsis in nonvital pulp cases.2 Using various irrigation solutions, chemo-mechanical instrumentation has become the preferred protocol by most clinicians. Flushing the irrigation solution in the canal space is reported to be ineffective in elimination of bacteria from canal space; therefore, antibacterial action of the irrigation solution might be the desired property of the solution.3
Phytotherapeutic potential of herbal essential oils as irrigation solutions and interappointment intracanal medications is gaining more popularity in recent years. Herbal irrigation solutions are generally considered as safe and nontoxic for the host and some have proved to be strong antibacterial materials in-vitro. Antibacterial effect of green tea, Morinda citrifolia, Zataria multiflora Boiss extract in infected canals has been investigated.4-6 Satureja Khuzistanica Jamzad (SKJ), an endemic plant in southern parts of Iran, has been used by the nomads to relieve the tooth pain for hundreds of years.7 Antibacterial, antifungal, antiviral activity and also antiinflammatory effect of SKJ essential oil are reported.8,9 Seghatoleslami et al.10 tested SKJ essential oil against eleven common oral bacteria and came to the interestingly low concentration of 0.31 mg/ml as the minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) of the essential oil. SKJ was found to have substantive property up to 21 days on the bovine dentin.11 Therefore, the aim of this in-vitro study was to evaluate the antibacterial effect of endemic SKJ essential oil, sodium hypochlorite and chlorhexidine gluconate solutions as root canal irrigation solutions within root canal space.
Materials and Methods
Collection and preparation of the samples In this in vitro experimental study, fifty four single canal maxillary and mandibular bicuspids were collected and stored in normal saline to prevent dehydration. Number of the canals was verified by periapical radiographs and samples were visually inspected for existence of defects such as external resorption, crack and caries. All samples were decoronated at CEJ level using high speed diamond fissure bur (Tizkavan, Tehran, Iran). Working lengths were determined with K-file #10 (FKG Dentaire, La Chaux-de- Fonds, Switzerland) and range of root length was between 12-15 mm. Rotary root canal instrumentation was performed as outlined below: race #40, 10 (FKG Dentaire, La Chaux- de- Fonds/ Switzerland) in 1/3 coronal section, race #35, 0.08 for 1/3 middle part and finally, race #30, 0.06 for 1/3 apical section. Irrigation was performed after each instrument application by flushing 2 ml of normal saline. To eliminate smear layer, 10 ml of 17% EDTA (Aria Dent, Asia ChemiTeb, Tehran, Iran) was used for one minute followed by 5 ml of 5.25 % NaOCl (Golrang, Pakshoo Co. Tehran, Iran), subsequently. To prevent apical leakage, apex of the roots was sealed with composite resin (Amelogen, UltraDent, Utah, USA). Each tooth was autoclaved in a cryo tube containing brain heart infusion (BHI) medium (Merck Co., Germany).
Irrigation solutions The essential oil of SKJ was obtained from Khorraman Co. Lorestan, Iran. Chemical analysis of the essential oil by gas chromatography/mass spectrometry (GC/MS) revealed that the major components of the SKJ essential oil are carvacrol (93%), eugenol (1%), P-cymene (0.8%) and thymol (0.6%).7 Our previous in-vitro study assessing the antibacterial activity of SKJ essential oil provided MIC value of 0.31 mg/ml against nine oral pathogens.10 SKJ essential oil was diluted in Di methyl sulfoxide
(DMSO) to reach the final concentrations of 2 MIC and MIC which were compared to 2.5% sodium hypochlorite (Pars Co., Tehran, Iran) and 2% chlorhexidine gluconate (Consepsis, Ultradent, Utah, USA) as two common irrigation solutions in root canal environment in-vitro.
Enterococcus faecalis ATCC 29212 was used as challenging microorganism. The bacterial suspension was prepared by suspending overnight colonies from Caso agar medium (Merck Co., Germany) in 0.9% saline. The bacterial suspension was adjusted photometrically at 600 nm to a cell density equivalent to approximately 0.5 McFarland standard (1.5×108 CFU/ml).
The teeth were randomly divided into 6 groups of 9 samples. The groups consisted of 2.5% sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl), 2% chlorhexidine gluconate (CHX), 0.31 mg/ml SKJ, 0.62 mg/ml SKJ, positive and negative controls.
Under aseptic conditions, each tooth (except negative controls) was removed from the cryo tube and the canal was dried with a sterile #30 paper point (Sendoline, Solna, Sweden). Then, the canal was filled with bacterial suspension by using a sterile insulin syringe. The inoculated tooth was transferred to the cryo tube containing BHI medium and incubated at 35oC under microaerophilic condition (MART system, 5% CO2, 5.9% O2, 7.2% H2, 79% N2) for 48 h.
After incubation, the tooth was removed from cryo tube and the canals were washed 3 times with 10 ml sterile saline using a sterile insulin syringe and dried with a sterile #30 paper point (Sendoline, Solna, Sweden). Then, each canal was filled with irrigation solution using a sterile insulin syringe. After 5 minute exposure, the canal was dried with sterile paper point and filled with soy-lecithin-poly sorbate 20 (Merck Co., Germany) for inactivation of the antibacterial agent. The inactivator was removed after 5 min with sterile paper point. The positive controls were inoculated with bacterial suspension but were exposed to sterile saline instead of irrigation solution.
For determination of viable bacterial count after each treatment, dentin chips were collected by intracanal sampling using #40 hand HedstrÖm files. The mean amount of collected dentin chips from each canal was 0.1 grams. Dentin chips were transferred into 10 ml sterile saline containing 1% Tween 80 and were shaken vigorously for 30 sec to separate the bacteria. The viable bacterial counts were determined by plating 1 ml aliquots of resulting suspension using caso agar medium. After 48 h incubation of the plates at 35oC under microaerophilic condition, the bacterial colonies were counted and expressed as CFU (colony forming unit)/dentin chips.
Statistical analysis was performed by the SPSS 18 software. Statistical differences among solutions were determined by one-way ANOVA. To compare several groups, Tukey post-hoc test was applied and the mean differences with p<0.05 were considered statistically significant. The data was not normally distributed; therefore, the comparison between groups was done using Kruskal-Wallis one-way analysis of variance. The differences between the ranks of the groups with p<0.05 were considered statistically significant.
Mean number of bacteria in positive control group (n=9) after a period of 48 h incubation was 2.45×104 CFU/dentin chips (Table 1). Mean number of bacteria after five minutes contact with NaOCl 2.5 % was 1.5×10¹ CFU/dentin chips and 12.3×10¹ CFU/dentin chips for CHX 2% group which showed 99.94 % and 99.50% reduction in bacterial load, respectively (Figure 1). Mean number of bacteria after five minutes contact with MIC and 2 MIC concentrations of SKJ essential oil was 0.67×10¹ CFU/dentin chips and 0.95×10¹ CFU/dentin chips with 99.97% and 99.96% reduction in bacterial load, respectively. All 9 samples from the positive control group demonstrated bacterial growth. However, no visible bacterial growth was observed in negative control group. While there were differences in bacterial counts among all four experimental groups in comparison with the control group (P < 0.05), no significant differences among the four irrigation solutions were detected (P = 0.755).
Level of effectiveness of antibacterial agents might differ in root canal environment than what has been detected in laboratory tests; therefore, in a continuation of our previous investigation, SKJ essential oil was evaluated against E. faecalis in root canal environment in the current study.
Gentil et al.12 found the Arctium lappa extract to completely inhibit intracanal microorganisms’ growth at 14 and 30 days which seems to be rather a long period in clinical practice. Various green teas were tested against 24 bacterial strains in-vitro and found to be effective on many of them including obligative anaerobes and the action was contributed to the high contents of poly phenols which is mainly
catechin.4 Murray et al.5 inoculated canals with E. faecalis and found that the Morinda citrifolia effectively removed the smear layer, and suggested it as an alternative to NaOCl, but did not mention the probable antibacterial property of Noni juice. Compared to NaOCl 2.5 %, no significant difference of fifteen minutes contact of 1% and 2% Zataria multiflora against intracanal E. faecalis was detected, however such concentrations seem to be rather high and indication of weaker antibacterial property of the extract.6
It was shown that an over the counter product of SKJ essential oil (Dentol, Khorraman Co. Lorestan, Iran) reduced E. faecalis count on bovine dentin blocks up to 99.3% at the day 28, which is a promising point of substantivity property for the SKJ extract.11 But, the tested product was 10% solution of SKJ essential oil with di methyl sulfoxide (DMSO) solvent which is different from pure carvacrol and seems to be an unnecessarily high concentration and therefore, unsuitable to be used as intracanal irrigation solution. Although DMSO is considered to be neutral in bacterial activity studies, it is not considered as a safe agent for the host tissue cells.
In their pilot study, Nosrat et al.13 came to similar MIC values and reported that 6% SKJ to be as effective as E. faecalis as final flush and suggested as an acceptable alternative for NaOCl solution.
SKJ is an endemic plant with proven antibacterial, antifungal and antiviral effects. The major component of the plant is carvacrol, with wide range of antibacterial spectrum.14 Carvacrol inhibits the ATPase activity and leads to increased nonspecific permeability of bacterial cell membrane and lysis.15 Spectral analysis of methanolic extract of SKJ revealed the presence of flavones, triterpenoids and steroids, with excessive amounts of ursolic acid with known anti-inflammatory effects.16
Although sodium hypochlorite solution with various concentrations from 0.5% up to 5.25% has been widely used as intra-canal irrigation, its toxicity to vital periodontium tissues has been widely reported.17 Phenolic compounds such as Eugenol, CMCP, and Cresol have a long history of usage as intracanal medicament in endodontic practice but gradually disappeared from modern practice due to high irritation potential to periapex tissues. Contrary to other former phenolic compounds, the major advantage of the SKJ extract is its’ effectiveness in extremely low concentration. SKJ essential oil with MIC value as low as 0.31 mg/ml, has proved to be as effective as routine solutions such as NaOCl and CHX against resistant pathogens such as E. faecalis. Essential oils are generally considered as safe materials and biocompatibility studies have found SKJ essential oil to be highly safe for the vital host tissues.15 Considering the complexity of root canal system and the importance of eliminating necrotic pulp remnants in areas that mechanical instrumentation has limitations, soft tissue solubility of NaOCl seems to be advantageous to SKJ essential oil, and however, such property of the SKJ remains to be investigated.
SKJ essential oil with the MIC of 0.31 mg/ml might be considered as an effective antibacterial irrigation solution.
The authors are thankful to Khorraman Co. (Lorestan, Iran) for providing SKJ essential oil for this study.
1. Kakehashi S, Stanley HR, Fitzgerald RJ. The effects of surgical exposures of dental pulps in germ-free and conventional laboratory rats. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol 1965; 20(3): 340-9.
2. Zehnder M. Root canal irrigants. J Endod 2006; 32(5): 389-98.
3. Bystrom A, Sundqvist G. Bacteriologic evaluation of the efficacy of mechanical root canal instrumentation in endodontic therapy. Scand J Dent Res 1981; 89(4):321-8.
4. Horiba N, Maekawa Y, Ito M, Matsumoto T, Nakamura H. A pilot study of Japanese green tea as a medicament: antibacterial and bactericidal effects. J Endod 1991; 17(3):122-4.
5. Murray PE, Farber RM, Namerow KN, Kuttler S, Garcia-Godoy F. Evaluation of Morinda citrifolia as an endodontic irrigant. J Endod 2008; 34(1):66-70.
6. Ravanshad S, Basiri E, Mohammadzadeh M. An invitro evaluation of antibacterial effect of Zataria multiflora Boiss as an irrigant against Enterecoccus faecalis. Shiraz Univ Dent J 2009; 10(2): 92-8.
7. Farsam H, Amanlou M, Radpour MR, Salehinia AN, Shafiee A. Composition of the essential oils of wild and cultivated Satureja khuzistanica Jamzad from Iran. Flavour and Fragrance Journal 2004; 19(4): 308-10.
8. Amanlou M, Fazeli MR, Arvin A, Amin HG, Farsam H. Antimicrobial activity of crude methanolic extract of Satureja khuzistanica. Fitoterapia 2004; 75(7-8): 768-70.
9. Amanlou M, Dadkhah F, Salehnia A, Farsam H, Dehpour AR. An anti-inflammatory and antinociceptive effects of hydroalcoholic extract of Satureja khuzistanica Jamzad extract. J Pharm Pharm Sci 2005; 8(1): 102-1.
10. Seghatoleslami S, Samadi N, Salehnia A, Azimi Sh. Antibacterial activity of endemic Satureja Khuzistanica Jamzad essential oil against oral pathogens. IEJ 2009; 4(1): 5-9.
11. Sharifian MR, Shokouhinejad N, Aligholi M, Emaneini M, Alizadeh MJ. Antibacterial substantivity of Carvacrol and sodium hypochlorite in infected bovine root dentin. IEJ 2009; 4(2): 45-8.
12. Gentil M, Pereira JV, Sousa YT et al. In vitro evaluation of the antibacterial activity of Arctium lappa as a phytotherapeutic agent used in intracanal dressings. Phytother Res 2006; 20(3): 184-6.
13. Nosrat A, Bolhari B, Sharifian MR, Aligholi M, Mortazavi MS. The effect of Carvacrol on Enterococcus faecalis as a final irrigant. IEJ 2009; 4(3): 96-100.
14. Gill AO, Holley RA. Disruption of Escherichia coli, Listeria monocytogenes and Lactobacillus sakei cellular membranes by plant oil aromatics. Int J Food Microbiol 2006; 108(1): 1-9.
15. Helander IM, Alakomi HL, Latva-Kala K et al. Characterization of the Action of Selected Essential Oil Components on Gram-Negative Bacteria. J Agric Food Chem 1998; 46(9): 3590-5.
16. Moghaddam FM, Farimani MM, Salahvarzi S, Amin G. Chemical Constituents of Dichloromethane Extract of Cultivated Satureja khuzistanica. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med 2007; 4(1): 95-8.
17. Spencer HR, Ike V, Brennan PA. Review: the use of sodium hypochlorite in endodontics--potential complications and their management. Br Dent J 2007; 202(9): 555-9.